Thursday, November 19, 2026

The Detective Story: Novel or Romance?

Okay, I admit it: my title is only a grabber. A single blog posting is not the place to answer such a big question. Instead I'm going to write about three things:

First, the detective story is said to have started with three stories by Edgar Allan Poe (1809-1849) featuring his eccentric but otherwise flawless detective C. Auguste Dupin. In a letter to Phillip P. Cook, dated August 9, 1846, Poe called his detective stories "tales of ratiocination," mentioning "Murders in the Rue Morgue" by name, ratiocination being defined elsewhere as a "methodical and logical reasoning." It seems like a "tale of ratiocination" would not easily fall into the category of weird fiction. Nonetheless "Murders in the Rue Morgue" has its weird elements, and it was in fact the cover story of the June 1923 issue of Weird Tales.

Logic and reason would seem to occupy a spot opposite emotion, passion, and irrationality. The tendency might be to think of the detective story as realistic, thus novelistic: the detective is like a scientist, his mind governed not by irrationality but by reason. If anything, it is the criminal who is passionate and irrational, seemingly the proper subject of a Romance or Gothic tale.

On November 17, 2023, in an entry entitled "Edgar Allan Poe in the First Year of Weird Tales," I wrote:

The protagonist of the horror story is flawed--physically, mentally, or morally weak or deficient, if not insane. Maybe he is in a long line descended from Jack Williamson's Egyptian-Hebraic hero and a progenitor of the weird-fictional hero of the twentieth century. The Poesque detective, on the other hand, possesses a level and piercing intellect. Later American detectives, being flawed antiheroes, have more in common with the weird-fictional hero. British detectives, perhaps their French counterparts, too, also some prissy Americans, are at a higher level of society. In any event, the tale of ratiocination can be seen as the beginning not only of the detective story but also as a beginning of the science fiction story with its strong, able, and triumphant hero, a man who applies science and reason to all problems, thereby solving them. The bad part about all of that is that there may be very little of the human in the problem and especially in the problem-solving. Otis Adelbert Kline's Dr. Dorp, for example, is basically nonhuman. It's worth noting here that in an essay entitled "Edgar Allan Poe," D.H. Lawrence wrote:

     But Poe is rather a scientist than and artist. He is reducing his own self as a scientist reduces a salt in a crucible. It is an almost chemical analysis of the soul and consciousness. (p. 111)

That essay was published in 1923 of all years. (It was reprinted in The Recognition of Poe, edited by Eric W. Carlson and published in 1966, which is my source for the quote above.) If you read Poe, you might be struck by a lack of moral sense. Maybe he was more a scientist than artist after all. On the other hand, if his subject was himself, then he was both the rational scientist and the tormented and passionate individual placed on the examination table or under the microscope, in other words, a human being and perhaps an artist after all.

I won't argue with D.H. Lawrence's interpretation of Poe as a scientist. I'll also point out that Lawrence was almost certainly not referring to a character like C. Auguste Dupin so much as to Poe's passionate, wild, and crazed fictional counterparts as the subject of Poe's investigations. That leaves Dupin as a scientist-type character and Poe's detective stories as being possibly realistic versus his more romantic stories, such as "The Fall of the House of Usher."

I should add that if the detective is like a scientist, then there may be a connection between the detective story and the science fiction story. Applying science, reason, and logic to every problem and mystery, Mr. Spock may be the ultimate detective.

I'll add even more: "Ooze" by Anthony M. Rud (Weird Tales, Mar. 1923) and "The Call of Cthulhu" by H.P. Lovecraft (Weird Tales, Feb. 1928) are both murder mysteries, among other things. The narrators in both stories are detectives. Both stories are science fantasies, in other words, they bridge whatever gap there might be between science fiction and weird fiction or horror. Rud's story is more science fiction-like and more even in tone. Despite his scientific training and demeanor, Lovecraft's narrator is closer to the edge of fear and hysteria. But then he has reason to be, for he realizes that his life is in danger and that the Cthulhu crisis still threatens the world.

So is the detective a realistic versus a romantic type of character? And is the detective story at its heart novelistic, or is it romantic?

Second, I recently found a book called Detective Fiction: Crime and Compromise, edited by Dick Allen and David Chacko, and published in 1974 as a college textbook. I may have a later printing, but if this book is fifty-two years old, it doesn't show it. It is in excellent condition. Anyway, I read with interest a brief essay called "A Defence [sic] of Detective Stories" by G.K. Chesterton, from 1902. In his essay, Chesterton described the poetry and romance of the city, specifically London, the milieu of the British detective, including Sherlock Holmes. Chesterton wrote of the human character of the city in contrast to the countryside and Nature as "a chaos of unconscious forces," specifically with this imagery:

But there is no stone in the street and no brick in the wall that is not actually a deliberate symbol--a message from some man, as much as if it were a telegram or a post-card. The narrowest street possesses, in every crook and twist of its intention, the soul of the man who built it, perhaps long in his grave.

I have long had an awareness of the continuing presence of the people of the past in the things they built and the places they inhabited. In peering down an alley or at the rear of a block of buildings, in looking upon the crumbling concrete of an old loading dock or a patch of abandoned parking lot or sidewalk, in studying rusted iron and steel, frayed and fallen wire and cables, flaking paint, cracked plaster, palimpsests of old advertising and signage, I feel they are still with us, if only in what they made. Need there be more? The passage of time may be only an illusion: somewhere, it is all still going on and they all yet live.

Third, Chesterton's closing paragraph is long, but it gets at truths about us as human beings and at the detective as ultimately a romantic figure:

     There is, however, another good work that is done by detective stories. While it is the constant tendency of the Old Adam to rebel against so universal and automatic a thing as civilization, to preach departure and rebellion, the romance of police activity keeps in some sense before the mind the fact that civilization itself is the most sensational of departures and the most romantic of rebellions. By dealing with the unsleeping sentinels who guard the outposts of society, it tends to remind us that we live in an armed camp, making war with a chaotic world, and that the criminals, the children of chaos, are nothing but the traitors within our gates. When the detective in a police romance stands alone, and somewhat fatuously fearless amid the knives and fists of a thieves' kitchen, it does certainly serve to make us remember that it is the agent of social justice who is the original and poetic figure; while the burglars and footpads are merely placid old cosmic conservatives, happy in the immemorial respectability of apes and wolves. The romance of the police force is thus the whole romance of man. It is based on the fact that morality is the most dark and daring of conspiracies. It reminds us that the whole noiseless and unnoticeable police management by which we are ruled and protected is only a successful knight-errantry.

The detective, then, as a defender of civilization and morality, is in romantic rebellion in favor of order and against a primordial chaos, the agents of which are the criminals who act out from under him. I have read before of a comparison between the detective and the knight-errant, specifically to do with Raymond Chandler's Philip Marlowe. It's nice to see that image in an essay from more than a century ago and before the hardboiled school of American detective fiction began. There is a lot more to take from that last paragraph and a lot more to think about and write about--for instance, can there be a romantic order? or, is chaos conservative?--but this is enough for today.

Original text copyright 2026 Terence E. Hanley

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Another Sleeper Awakes

As I was reading through What's in a Novel by Helen E. Haines (1942), I came upon a description of a book I had never heard of but which fits into one of the themes of this blog. The book is entitled The First to Awaken (1940), and it was written by Granville Hicks (1901-1982). I didn't know it until just now, but Granville Hicks taught as McGuffey Visiting Professor of English at Ohio University in 1967-1968, and so we can add him to the list of authors who taught at that institution. Click here for a link.

The First to Awaken is a utopian novel of the future. As in other novels of this type, a man of our time sleeps his way into the future. The protagonist, George Swain, with the help of a scientist, goes to sleep in 1940 and awakens exactly a century later, in 2040, into a socialist America. Hicks was a socialist, as was science fiction author Mack Reynolds (1917-1983), who wrote After Utopia (1977), a similar kind of story in which a man of today sleeps his way into the future. Reynolds' protagonist awakens in the future of 2045 rather than 2040. I wonder whether Mack Reynolds was inspired by that previous novel by his fellow-traveler in socialism and in the making of literary Utopias. As an aside: it may have been only a coincidence that Granville Hicks wrote his novel at around the same time that the term "woke"--which has been adopted by socialists, progressives, and critical theorists of today--was first recorded as a synonym for being politically aware. The implication in Hicks' title is that to be a socialist is to be on the leading edge of thought and development and that to awaken into socialism is to come out of the deep, dark, and perhaps nightmarish sleep of the past and of tradition.

I have written before about the science fiction convention of sleeping into the future. First came "After Utopia by Mack Reynolds," from October 16, 2022, then "Sleep," from December 21, 2025. Hover and click to read.

Ms. Haines wrote a worthy summary of The First to Awaken. Rather than transcribe it, I will provide a scan:

You can read other summaries and reviews in contemporaneous newspaper articles.

Many of those articles included the name of the illustrator as a co-author or co-creator of The First to Awaken. His name was Richard M. Bennett. I have found records on a Richard Marsh Bennett (b. Feb. 4, 1907, Braddock, Pa.; d. May 2, 1996, Boston, Mass.), who graduated from Harvard University in 1928 and 1931. He worked as an architect and before that as a designer of posters and neon signs. His drawings on the endpapers of The First to Awaken, shown below, are architectural in nature. The times, places, associations, and middle initial would all seem right for Richard Marsh Bennett to have been the artist on The First to Awaken, but I can't say that he was for sure. There was another artist by the name of Richard Bennett who contributed to Weird Tales. He was by all accounts Richard Francis Bennett (1899-1971), who was born in Ireland and lived in Washington State, where he created illustrations for many children's books. But he is a subject for another day.

Text copyright 2026 Terence E. Hanley

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Regionalism Revisted

On August 27, 2026, I wrote about weird fiction and regional fiction. You can find what I wrote by clicking here.

While I was away, I found a book called What's in a Novel, written by Helen E. Haines (1872-1961) of New York City, later of New Mexico and Southern California. What's in a Novel was published in 1942 by Columbia University Press. It was designed, I think, for librarians, but anyone interested in literature is bound to gain by perusing its pages. What's in a Novel is model of clarity and completeness. It's like a snapshot from more than eight decades ago: I read about novels that have probably long been forgotten but nonetheless sound very interesting and worth a look.

I have a copy from the fourth printing from 1960. I found it at a secondhand store in central Indiana. My copy was withdrawn from the library where I went to college the first time around. It must have been in the stacks while I was going to school there. That's a strange thing to think about. I don't recognize any of the names in the back of the book. These people, mostly nuns, checked out What's in a Novel long before I read from that library.

In Chapter II, Helen E. Haines wrote:

If we no longer keep the formal distinctions between the romance and the novel, it is because "novel" is the term now commonly accepted to denote all prose fiction except the short story.

and:

     The romance once wove elaborate tapestries of chivalry and love and heroic combat; in its familiar meaning a romance is still a tale of love. It drew upon the supernatural, turned to fantasy and allegory, invested adventure and peril with glamor, was seeded with horror by the "Gothic tale," and enshrined both passion and sentimentality. Its transmigrations bring us the modern fiction of fantasy, allegory, symbolism, satire, and make-believe [. . .] and of exotic adventure [. . .]. (p. 17)

I think it important to hold onto the distinction between the romance and the novel. That distinction helps us keep our thoughts clear. It's important, too, to remember that what we call "romance"--the love story--is only a subset of the original and much broader category Romance. I was happy to find the phrase "Gothic tale" in the pages of this book.

In Chapter IV, Ms. Haines wrote:

     So we approach the domain of regional fiction. [. . .] In the United States the regional has become one of the most extensive fields of modern fiction: a medium for the observation and depiction of natural scene or human habitat, in fauna, flora, topographical characteristics, folk backgrounds, customs, speech, influences and environment, tradition, and processes of growth, in all sections and many localities of the country.

She added:

There has been no such development elsewhere, in mass and variety, although regional novels exist in almost every part of the world. (p. 67)

A long and detailed discussion of regional fiction follows, including mention of a book called American Regionalism (1938), which lists "more than 2,000 regional novels published during the past two decades" (p. 73), in other words, from circa 1922 to 1942. Those years are inclusive of the first two decades (almost) of Weird Tales magazine. The implication here is that Weird Tales, from its first issue in March 1923 until the outset of World War II, was published during a time when American regional fiction was at its peak--if I am right that regionalism declined during and after the war years. I'll add that a teller of weird tales earned mention on that same page:

August Derleth paints a detailed canvas of his native Wisconsin in his sequence of Sac Prairie saga novels, which run, in varying perspective, through regional annals of nearly a century. [Boldface added.] (p.67)

The author closed her chapter with a list of one hundred American regional novels published since 1930. Included in that list is another teller of weird tales, Harry Harrison Kroll (1888-1967), originally of Indiana, later of Tennessee. She devoted later chapters to the Romance--fantasy, the Gothic tale, utopian fiction, and even science fiction--and stories of crime, mystery, and detection, including Edgar Allan Poe's three stories of ratiocination and his detective C. Auguste Dupin.

The last chapter is on reviewing books. In addition to being a writer, editor, librarian, and teacher, Helen E. Haines was a book reviewer. I found a review, dated August 1, 1948, of Strange Ports of Call, edited by August Derleth and published in 1948 by Pellegrini & Cudahy. Ms. Haines' byline is not specifically on this review, but it is on the one preceding it. I would like to think that she was indeed the reviewer, for this may be the only example of her putting H.P. Lovecraft's name into print, this for his authorship of "At the Mountains of Madness," which was included in Strange Ports of Call.

American literature, at least early on, is more nearly romantic than realistic or novelistic. Weird Tales magazine continued in the American Romantic tradition. And, again, its first two decades coincided with a period of Regionalism in our literature. There are, to be sure, non-regional stories in its pages, plus plenty of science fiction or nascent science fiction, a genre that doesn't easily fit into the category of Regionalism, if at all. But it helps to see Weird Tales in the context of American Romanticism and Regionalism.

Original text copyright 2026 Terence E. Hanley

Friday, November 13, 2026

Star Trek Inspirations

My program for this year was to have been to convert drafts into published blog entries. Life has its way of rolling over programs and plans.

Right now I have twenty-four drafts. Most of these will have to remain drafts for the foreseeable future. Now that I'm on the subject of Star Trek, though, I can turn one of my drafts into an entry, even if it's just a fragment of what could actually be a longer essay and analysis.

Star Trek didn't come along fully formed. There were forerunners in science fiction in print and on film. Last time around, I wrote about three Gothic episodes of Star Trek:

  • "The Squire of Gothos"--Written by Paul Schneider, first broadcast on January 12, 1967. I mentioned that there are elements of The Wizard of Oz and "The Most Dangerous Game"  by Richard Connell (Collier's, Jan. 19, 1924) in this episode, but I don't think it was inspired by Connell's story. "The Squire of Gothos" can be included in the fiction of mirrors, though, a new category of story (I think) that could lead to a new draft, but then I would get nowhere at all in reducing my number of drafts.
  • "Catspaw"--Written by Robert Bloch, first broadcast on October 27, 1967. Based on Bloch's short story "Broomstick Ride" (Super-Science Fiction, Dec. 1957).
  • "Wolf in the Fold"--Written by Robert Bloch, first broadcast on December 22, 1967. Presumably based, in part, on Bloch's story "Yours Truly, Jack the Ripper" (Weird Tales, July 1943).
So Robert Bloch based two of his Star Trek scripts on his own short stories. The subject of today's entry is a story of a different type, though. That type is an episode of Star Trek that drew from or was inspired by stories or productions by creators who were not the authors of the Star Trek script. I have five examples. I'm sure there are others.
  • "The Man Trap" by George Clayton Johnson (Sept. 8, 1966), specifically the vampire creature, seems to have been inspired by "Black Destroyer" by A.E. van Vogt, originally in Astounding Science-Fiction in July 1939.
  • "Operation--Annihilate" by Steven W. Carabatsos (Apr. 13, 1967) seems to have been inspired by The Puppet Masters by Robert A. Heinlein, originally serialized in Galaxy Science Fiction in September, October, and November 1951.
  • "The Apple" by Max Ehrlich and Gene L. Coon (Oct. 13, 1967) is very close to being a reworking of the movie version of The Time Machine (1960), written by David Duncan and adapted from the novella by H.G. Wells (1895).
  • "The Trouble with Tribbles" by David Gerrold (Dec. 29, 1967) seems to have been based in part on The Rolling Stones by Robert A. Heinlein (1952), which had an earlier inspiration in the short story "Pigs Is Pigs" by Ellis Parker Butler (1905).
  • "Wink of an Eye" by Gene L. Coon and Arthur Heinemann (Nov. 29, 1968) seems to have been inspired by "The New Accelerator" by H.G. Wells, originally in The Strand Magazine, December 1901.
This could go and on. If you have additions to make, please leave comments below.

Text copyright 2026 Terence E. Hanley

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Star Trek Gothic

Like Dark Shadows, the television series Star Trek began in 1966. What I have called the Gothic Revival in our culture had begun several years before, possibly in about 1960. Dark Shadows is in the genre of the Gothic Romance and began as the girl-meets-house-type of Gothic Romance. Star Trek is of course a science fiction show. But the popularity of the Gothic Romance and Gothic culture clearly spilled over into Star Trek as early as its first season, most obviously in the episode "The Squire of Gothos," written by Don McDougall (1917-1991) and first broadcast on January 12, 1967.

The first Gothic Romance in fiction was The Castle of Otranto by Horace Walpole (1717-1797), first published on Christmas Eve in 1764. Trelane, the title character of "The Squire of Gothos," inhabits a castle of his own. His dress is eighteenth century. The setting, then, is appropriate for a Gothic Romance. Just in case we miss the reference, the place name "Gothos" lets us know that this episode of Star Trek is meant to bring back the Gothic past. There are elements of The Wizard of Oz and "The Most Dangerous Game" in "The Squire of Gothos." I have often thought that William Campbell (1923-2011), who played Trelane, and the unrelated Bruce Campbell (b. 1958) could have played a father and son in a television show of the imagination.

The Star Trek episode "Catspaw," first broadcast on October 27, 1967 (appropriate for Halloween), was written by Robert Bloch (1917-1994). He based his teleplay on his own story "Broomstick Ride," from Super-Science Fiction, December 1957. The Gothic content in "Catspaw" is far more extensive than in "The Squire of Gothos." It includes of course a castle, but there are also three witches like the three Weird Sisters in Shakespeare's Macbeth. Actress Antoinette Bower (1932-2026) memorably played the shapeshifting cat-woman. "Catspaw" was the first filmed episode of Star Trek in which Walter Koenig (1936-2026) appeared as Ensign Chekov.

Robert Bloch also wrote the teleplay for the episode "Wolf in the Fold," first broadcast on December 22, 1967. I have not read this anywhere, but it seems to me that "Wolf in the Fold" is based, at least in part, on Bloch's short story "Yours Truly, Jack the Ripper," originally in Weird Tales in July 1943. If that's the case, then "Wolf in the Fold" would seem to be the only story originally in Weird Tales that was adapted to an episode of Star Trek. That makes me think that stories by H.P. Lovecraft would have made great starting points for other episodes. One that springs to mind is "The Shadow Out of Time," originally in Astounding Stories in June 1936. By the way, Lovecraft would have understood Trelane's desire to live in the eighteenth century. If only he could have traveled back in time himself.

There are other episodes of Star Trek with Gothic themes, moods, settings, atmospheres, trappings, and so on, but these are the three that came to me as I considered the topic Star Trek Gothic. Realizing that the Gothic Revival of the 1960s made its way into the very remote genre of science fiction leads me to think that there was Gothic content in other television shows of that time. It has been too long since I watched The Wild Wild West (1965-1969), but I'm pretty sure there were Gothic elements and possibly Gothic episodes in that show. I welcome other suggestions and observations.

* * *

I have been away for a long time, six and a half weeks in all. I spent a good deal of one of the most beautiful Octobers in the history of Midwestern Octobers in an oubliette. But now I'm back. I had planned to write on the topic Star Trek Gothic in September in observance of the 60th anniversary of Star Trek. I'm glad I waited, although it is for unhappy reasons. Antoinette Bower, who was in "Catspaw" and other Gothic, Romantic, weird-fictional, and horror productions, died earlier this year at the age of 93. Michael Forest, who played the god Apollo in the Star Trek episode "'Who Mourns for Adonais?'", died on October 14, 2026, at age 97. He was followed in death eleven days later by Walter Koenig. I had the pleasure of meeting Mr. Koenig many years ago in Columbus, Ohio. I will remember him as a good person and a good actor. Three days after that, Patrick Stewart died at age 86. It's strange to think that he was only four years younger than young Chekov.

* * *

I'll close with a quick exercise in comparison and contrast brought on by my thoughts on the topic Star Trek Gothic:

I think of science fiction as being civilized and urban, strong and steady and cerebral. In contrast, I see weird fiction and the Gothic Romance as wild, emotional, non-civilized, and rural. I don't want to stretch this idea too thinly, nor to intellectualize things too much, but maybe science fiction can be seen as Apollonian, whereas weird fiction and the Gothic Romance are more nearly Dionysian. Star Trek, as a science fiction show, is civilized and urban. The Enterprise is a city in space. Its officers and crew are civilized, controlled, and scientific in their approach to the challenges and problems placed before them. (A very emotional Doctor McCoy is an exception. A hot-blooded Captain Kirk is very often another.) Part of the stated mission of the Enterprise is "to seek out new life and new civilizations," emphasis added. However, there are, as we have seen, at least three Gothic episodes of Star Trek, and there are many episodes in which its characters are thrust into wild, uncontrolled, and non-civilized situations. They actually perform pretty well in those situations, evidence perhaps that civilization is a veneer and that we are at heart wildmen. Star Trek also followed close on the heels of The Outer Limits (1963-1965) and early on had a monster-of-the-week or alien-of-the-week feel to it. If aliens are a type of monster, and monsters are in the domain of weird fiction or horror fiction, then the science-fictional alien or monster would seem closely tied to those much older and wilder genres. And on the opposite end of its Gothic episodes are the highly civilized episodes of Star Trek, one of which may have been the literally Apollonian episode "'Who Mourns for Adonais?'"

Happy Sixtieth Anniversary to

Star Trek!

Original text copyright 2026 Terence E. Hanley

Tuesday, September 29, 2026

Goth Girls-Part Four

In looking for the origins of the Goth Girl, one thing you might do is to go looking for the term. That's what I did. I searched for "goth girl" in newspapers online. The first occurrence of  "goth girl" that I found is in a review of a performance by the British band The Wonder Stuff, written by Andy Lane and published in the Tamworth Herald (England) on February 11, 1988. I suspect the term was in use well before then. It usually takes awhile before people in a larger or wider culture notice the things that develop in subcultures. (When other people notice is usually when a thing gets ruined, at least in the minds of the people who are already in that subculture.) I also found a reference in 1989 to All About Eve, a "sub-goth girl band," performing in Manchester, England. So it looks like "goth girl" was a British thing first, and that fits with the idea that the Goth Girl look started with Siouxsie Sioux and other British musicians, singers, and fans. I wrote earlier this summer about Manchester and some of its musicians. Maybe they can be proud to have had the first Goth types.

According to my search results, the term "goth girl" or "Goth girl" was used a few times every year during the 1990s. It got a lot more attention in regards to the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC) television show Straight Up and its character Lily, played by Sarah Polley. In an article about the show, reviewer Bonnie Malleck explained that a "goth" girl is "sort of a teenage version of spook show host Elvira." (Boldface added.) That fits with the idea that the Goth Girl is descended from the Elvira-Vampira-Morticia look of the 1930s through the mid 1980s. Ms. Malleck's article was in the Waterloo Region Record, Ontario, Canada, on March 30, 1996. The fact that she had to explain what a Goth Girl is means that the type and the look were still not well known by that name.

Early on, meaning in the 1980s and '90s, the term "goth" girl or "goth girl" appeared in quotation marks. By about 1997, the quotation marks had begun disappearing, signifying, I think, that the term Goth girl had become one that people were supposed to know or be familiar with already. Occurrences of Goth girl picked up after that until there were hundreds every year in the early 2000s. The peak year according to what I found was in 2007, when Goth girl was in newspapers 600 times.

I found an online article dated October 29, 2025, entitled "Goth-Girl Style Owes Everything To Winona Ryder." The blurb below the title reads: "From '90s muse to Tim Burton goth, Winona Ryder's legacy of red-carpet looks proves that goth-girl leanings will never go out of style." (Boldface added.) The article is on the website British Vogue. The reference is to Winona Ryder in the film Beetlejuice, released in 1988. It looks like we can still date the development of the Goth Girl look to the late 1980s.

A related look is the emo girl look. Ally Sheedy in The Breakfast Club (1985) is kind of an emo girl. Goth Girls and emo girls, or Emo Girls, include the girl from The Ring (2002); the character Abby Sciuto, played by Pauly Perrette in NCIS (2003 and after); the girl from The Incredibles (2004); Raven from Teen Titans Go! (2013 and after); and of course Wednesday Addams in various movies and TV shows. Those dates point to a peak year or years during the early 2000s, or around the same time that zombies (another Gothic type) were so wildly popular and started eating the brains of consumers. It looks like the same thing happened with Goth Girls and Emo Girls as what happened with Gothic Romances and stories in the 1960s: a thing starts out slow and small, it picks up speed, and then it becomes very popular and commodified, or commodified and very popular, before reaching a peak and then fading away. There is always the next big thing to take the place of the last big thing. There are still Goth Girls, but has the type become just a stereotype? Is there any room left in our culture for a new or interesting Goth Girl?

Now for some cuttings and scrapings:

Other possible influences on the Goth look: Vampires from literature and film, including Gloria Holden as the title role in Dracula's Daughter (1936); Margaret Hamilton in The Wizard of Oz (1939); Gale Sondergaard in The Blue Bird (1940); Judith Anderson in Rebecca (1940); the Nazi SS; 1950s and '60s motorcycle gangs and motorcycle movies; and plenty of musicians from the 1970s and '80s, including Alice Cooper, the Ramones, KISS, Joan Jett, Patti Smith, Chrissie Hynde (another September birthday), . . .

Original text copyright 2026 Terence E. Hanley

Saturday, September 26, 2026

Goth Girls-Part Three

I have been going through the vaults of my brain trying to think of early Goth Girls. I'm sure that the basic Goth Girl goes back a long way, but what about the specific look of the late twentieth century? Siouxsie Sioux of Siouxsie and the Banshees seems to have inspired scads of dark-haired girls and young women who, over the years and decades, have taken to wearing black clothing, black accessories, and black eye makeup. But was there anyone before her? I think of the character Jacqueline Gibson from the movie The Seventh Victim (1943), played by Jean Brooks, as an early Goth Girl. I wonder if her look could have been inspired by another fictional character who made her first appearance just five years before.

Charles Addams (1912-1988) drew more than a thousand gag cartoons during his decades-long career. His first for The New Yorker is from February 4, 1933. His first illustrating a family and household that would eventually bear his name came along on August 6, 1938. It depicts the character who would become Morticia Addams. At her side is, I think, an early version of Lurch. Addams went on to create 58 cartoons featuring his Gothic characters in their Gothic house. With her black hair, pale skin, black dress, and dour expression, the matriarch of Addams' cartoon family seems to have been a model for the Goth Girl, or a model for models.

On May 1, 1954, The Vampira Show premiered on KABC-TV in Los Angeles. The title character, played by Maila Nurmi (1922-2008), was the first television horror hostess (before any horror host). Maila Nurmi is supposed to have based the look of her character on Charles Addams' as yet unnamed cartoon matriarch. I wrote recently about the Googie style of architecture, named after Googie's Coffee Shop in Los Angeles. That's where the woman who played Vampira met James Dean (1931-1955). They became friends. Like Charles Addams, James Dean was a car enthusiast. The former suffered a heart attack in his car and died in a hospital on September 29, 1988. The latter was killed in a car crash on September 30, 1954. This week is one of anniversaries of deaths of prominent people, but I guess every week is like that. Alex Raymond, also a cartoonist and also a car enthusiast, also died in a car crash in September. His end came on September 6, 1956.

Elvira, Mistress of the Dark, was another television horror hostess. She was played by Cassandra Peterson, who was born on September 17, 1951. Yet another Happy Birthday! Elvira had her own local horror movie show in Los Angeles from 1981 to 1986. Her look was based on that of her predecessor, Vampira. And so Elvira was based on Vampira who was based on the character who would one day be named Morticia. Vampirella is a completely different character, even if she has dark hair and sometimes wears bangs.

Almost thirty years after her first appearance in a magazine gag cartoon, Morticia Addams got her own TV show called The Addams Family. It made its debut on September 18, 1964. Morticia was played to perfection by Carolyn Jones (1930-1983). The actress was a natural blonde but played one brunette or dark-haired woman after another in movies and TV shows. She wore her natural hair color in Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1956). What a great movie and good, appealing, and attractive actress!

I have been writing about a Gothic revival that I think took place in the 1960s and early 1970s. In 1960, Paramount pictures released Psycho, directed by Alfred Hitchcock and with a screenplay by Joseph Stefano based on Robert Bloch's novel of 1959. (Bloch also had a September death date.) In that movie, a young woman, played by blonde Janet Leigh, gets in her car and attempts to drive away from the past. However, once she stops driving, she reencounters the past in the form of a psycho killer who lives, incongruously for that late date, in an Addams Family-style Gothic house. As in The Seventh Victim from seventeen years before, there is a shower scene in Psycho. Also as in that earlier film, the sister of the missing woman goes looking for her. Four years after Psycho was released, the Gothic house--a comic Gothic house--reappeared in The Addams Family television show. Unlike the heroine of the Gothic Romance, Morticia has no desire to run from her house. She is actually très heureuse there.

There is one more possible Goth Girl in today's entry. Like Jean Crane as Jacqueline Gibson, she had dark hair and wore bangs straight across her forehead. Her name was Barbara Jean Day. She was born in 1919 in Chicago and graduated from Butler University in Indianapolis in or about 1939. On May 29, 1943, she married Charles Addams in Westfield, New Jersey, a little less than two months before The Seventh Victim was released. I don't know when she started wearing bangs. She lacked them in her college yearbook picture. I wonder if she was influenced by a viewing of The Seventh Victim. I also wonder whether she was influenced in her general appearance by the Morticia Addams character. Or maybe Charles Addams went looking for women who reminded him of her. (Male artists sometimes fall in love with their creations.) Barbara Jean Day died on August 16, 2007. That was ten days after the sixty-second anniversary of the atomic bombing of Hiroshima, and sixty-nine years and ten days after the first Addams Family cartoon. Barbara Jean Day's second husband, John Hersey (1914-1993), wrote about the first atomic bombing in his book Hiroshima, first published in its entirety in the August 31, 1946, issue of The New Yorker. I wonder if Charles Addams had a cartoon in that issue, too.

An image of Charles Addams' original art for a cartoon published in The New Yorker in November 1939. This is one of my favorite of the Addams Family cartoons.

Charles Addams and Barbara Jean Day in a photograph that is pretty obviously staged. Despite what people have written about her, she could not have been the original for the character who would be named Morticia Addams. Addams drew Morticia before he ever met Barbara Jean. In 1938, when his first Addams family cartoon was published, she was a non-Goth-looking student at Butler University in Indianapolis. They did not meet until 1941 and were not married until 1943. And I'm pretty sure that's not an original drawing on his lap. It may be simply a tear sheet from The New Yorker. By the look of his haircut and the checked shirt, I would guess this is a postwar photograph, possibly from the late 1940s or early 1950s. Notice the Audubon print on the wall: those are his depictions of the common American gull.

Text copyright 2026 Terence E. Hanley