Okay, I admit it: my title is only a grabber. A single blog posting is not the place to answer such a big question. Instead I'm going to write about three things:
First, the detective story is said to have started with three stories by Edgar Allan Poe (1809-1849) featuring his eccentric but otherwise flawless detective C. Auguste Dupin. In a letter to Phillip P. Cook, dated August 9, 1846, Poe called his detective stories "tales of ratiocination," mentioning "Murders in the Rue Morgue" by name, ratiocination being defined elsewhere as a "methodical and logical reasoning." It seems like a "tale of ratiocination" would not easily fall into the category of weird fiction. Nonetheless "Murders in the Rue Morgue" has its weird elements, and it was in fact the cover story of the June 1923 issue of Weird Tales.
Logic and reason would seem to occupy a spot opposite emotion, passion, and irrationality. The tendency might be to think of the detective story as realistic, thus novelistic: the detective is like a scientist, his mind governed not by irrationality but by reason. If anything, it is the criminal who is passionate and irrational, seemingly the proper subject of a Romance or Gothic tale.
On November 17, 2023, in an entry entitled "Edgar Allan Poe in the First Year of Weird Tales," I wrote:
The protagonist of the horror story is flawed--physically, mentally, or morally weak or deficient, if not insane. Maybe he is in a long line descended from Jack Williamson's Egyptian-Hebraic hero and a progenitor of the weird-fictional hero of the twentieth century. The Poesque detective, on the other hand, possesses a level and piercing intellect. Later American detectives, being flawed antiheroes, have more in common with the weird-fictional hero. British detectives, perhaps their French counterparts, too, also some prissy Americans, are at a higher level of society. In any event, the tale of ratiocination can be seen as the beginning not only of the detective story but also as a beginning of the science fiction story with its strong, able, and triumphant hero, a man who applies science and reason to all problems, thereby solving them. The bad part about all of that is that there may be very little of the human in the problem and especially in the problem-solving. Otis Adelbert Kline's Dr. Dorp, for example, is basically nonhuman. It's worth noting here that in an essay entitled "Edgar Allan Poe," D.H. Lawrence wrote:
But Poe is rather a scientist than and artist. He is reducing his own self as a scientist reduces a salt in a crucible. It is an almost chemical analysis of the soul and consciousness. (p. 111)
That essay was published in 1923 of all years. (It was reprinted in The Recognition of Poe, edited by Eric W. Carlson and published in 1966, which is my source for the quote above.) If you read Poe, you might be struck by a lack of moral sense. Maybe he was more a scientist than artist after all. On the other hand, if his subject was himself, then he was both the rational scientist and the tormented and passionate individual placed on the examination table or under the microscope, in other words, a human being and perhaps an artist after all.
I won't argue with D.H. Lawrence's interpretation of Poe as a scientist. I'll also point out that Lawrence was almost certainly not referring to a character like C. Auguste Dupin so much as to Poe's passionate, wild, and crazed fictional counterparts as the subject of Poe's investigations. That leaves Dupin as a scientist-type character and Poe's detective stories as being possibly realistic versus his more romantic stories, such as "The Fall of the House of Usher."
I should add that if the detective is like a scientist, then there may be a connection between the detective story and the science fiction story. Applying science, reason, and logic to every problem and mystery, Mr. Spock may be the ultimate detective.
I'll add even more: "Ooze" by Anthony M. Rud (Weird Tales, Mar. 1923) and "The Call of Cthulhu" by H.P. Lovecraft (Weird Tales, Feb. 1928) are both murder mysteries, among other things. The narrators in both stories are detectives. Both stories are science fantasies, in other words, they bridge whatever gap there might be between science fiction and weird fiction or horror. Rud's story is more science fiction-like and more even in tone. Despite his scientific training and demeanor, Lovecraft's narrator is closer to the edge of fear and hysteria. But then he has reason to be, for he realizes that his life is in danger and that the Cthulhu crisis still threatens the world.
So is the detective a realistic versus a romantic type of character? And is the detective story at its heart novelistic, or is it romantic?
Second, I recently found a book called Detective Fiction: Crime and Compromise, edited by Dick Allen and David Chacko, and published in 1974 as a college textbook. I may have a later printing, but if this book is fifty-two years old, it doesn't show it. It is in excellent condition. Anyway, I read with interest a brief essay called "A Defence [sic] of Detective Stories" by G.K. Chesterton, from 1902. In his essay, Chesterton described the poetry and romance of the city, specifically London, the milieu of the British detective, including Sherlock Holmes. Chesterton wrote of the human character of the city in contrast to the countryside and Nature as "a chaos of unconscious forces," specifically with this imagery:
But there is no stone in the street and no brick in the wall that is not actually a deliberate symbol--a message from some man, as much as if it were a telegram or a post-card. The narrowest street possesses, in every crook and twist of its intention, the soul of the man who built it, perhaps long in his grave.
I have long had an awareness of the continuing presence of the people of the past in the things they built and the places they inhabited. In peering down an alley or at the rear of a block of buildings, in looking upon the crumbling concrete of an old loading dock or a patch of abandoned parking lot or sidewalk, in studying rusted iron and steel, frayed and fallen wire and cables, flaking paint, cracked plaster, palimpsests of old advertising and signage, I feel they are still with us, if only in what they made. Need there be more? The passage of time may be only an illusion: somewhere, it is all still going on and they all yet live.
Third, Chesterton's closing paragraph is long, but it gets at truths about us as human beings and at the detective as ultimately a romantic figure:
There is, however, another good work that is done by detective stories. While it is the constant tendency of the Old Adam to rebel against so universal and automatic a thing as civilization, to preach departure and rebellion, the romance of police activity keeps in some sense before the mind the fact that civilization itself is the most sensational of departures and the most romantic of rebellions. By dealing with the unsleeping sentinels who guard the outposts of society, it tends to remind us that we live in an armed camp, making war with a chaotic world, and that the criminals, the children of chaos, are nothing but the traitors within our gates. When the detective in a police romance stands alone, and somewhat fatuously fearless amid the knives and fists of a thieves' kitchen, it does certainly serve to make us remember that it is the agent of social justice who is the original and poetic figure; while the burglars and footpads are merely placid old cosmic conservatives, happy in the immemorial respectability of apes and wolves. The romance of the police force is thus the whole romance of man. It is based on the fact that morality is the most dark and daring of conspiracies. It reminds us that the whole noiseless and unnoticeable police management by which we are ruled and protected is only a successful knight-errantry.
The detective, then, as a defender of civilization and morality, is in romantic rebellion in favor of order and against a primordial chaos, the agents of which are the criminals who act out from under him. I have read before of a comparison between the detective and the knight-errant, specifically to do with Raymond Chandler's Philip Marlowe. It's nice to see that image in an essay from more than a century ago and before the hardboiled school of American detective fiction began. There is a lot more to take from that last paragraph and a lot more to think about and write about--for instance, can there be a romantic order? or, is chaos conservative?--but this is enough for today.
Original text copyright 2026 Terence E. Hanley



