Ninety-nine years ago this month, on November 3 and 4, 1927, floods ravaged the state of Vermont. According to sources, 85 people died, all but one of those in Vermont.
In October of this year, I stopped at an estate sale along U.S. Highway 40, the National Road, in east-central Indiana. In a dark loft above a garage, among piles of items of all kinds, I found a booklet called Stories and Pictures of the Vermont Flood, November 1927, compiled by R.E. Atwood and published by him in Burlington, Vermont, in the year of the flood. It contains thirty-two interior pages of photographs, text, and tables. Atwood gave the number of casualties as 55, but many bodies remained to be recovered after winter snows had melted.
I bought Stories and Pictures of the Vermont Flood, November 1927 not only because I like American history but also because I recognized in this booklet the real, historical background for H.P. Lovecraft's story "The Whisperer in Darkness," first published in Weird Tales in August 1931.
Lovecraft wrote:
The whole matter began, so far as I am concerned, with the historic and unprecedented Vermont floods of November 3, 1927. I was then, as now, an instructor of literature at Miskatonic University in Arkham, Massachusetts, and an enthusiastic amateur student of New England folklore. Shortly after the flood, amidst the varied reports of hardship, suffering, and organised relief which filled the press, there appeared certain odd stories of things found floating in some of the swollen rivers; so that many of my friends embarked on curious discussions and appealed to me to shed what light I could on the subject. I felt flattered at having my folklore study taken so seriously, and did what I could to belittle the wild, vague tales which seemed so clearly an outgrowth of old rustic superstitions. It amused me to find several persons of education who insisted that some stratum of obscure, distorted fact might underlie the rumours.
The tales thus brought to my notice came mostly through newspaper cuttings; though one yarn had an oral source and was repeated to a friend of mine in a letter from his mother in Hardwick, Vermont. The type of thing described was essentially the same in all cases, though there seemed to be three separate instances involved--one connected with the Winooski River near Montpelier, another attached to the West River in Windham County beyond Newfane, and a third centring [sic] in the Passumpsic in Caledonia County above Lyndonville. Of course many of the stray items mentioned other instances, but on analysis they all seemed to boil down to these three. In each case country folk reported seeing one or more very bizarre and disturbing objects in the surging waters that poured down from the unfrequented hills, and there was a widespread tendency to connect these sights with a primitive, half-forgotten cycle of whispered legend which old people resurrected for the occasion.
Three of the place names and geographical features mentioned by Lovecraft are also in Atwood's booklet, specifically, the Winooski River, Montpelier, and Lydonville.
There are accounts of terrible suffering and loss in this booklet from long ago. It was good of Lovecraft to wait three years before writing his story and for another year to go by before it was published. I'm not sure that he or his editor gave a respectful waiting any great consideration. It probably just happened that way. It takes time for a story idea to percolate, time for it to be written and put into print.
As in the later story of the Mothman and the Silver Bridge, Lovecraft linked a real-life disaster to a legend. One difference is that Lovecraft created his own fictional legend, whereas sightings of and encounters with Mothman were supposedly real, even if no one knows just what Mothman was. In other words, the legend of the Mothman grew up around supposedly real events, and it was left to two authors, first Gray Barker, then John Keel, to tie Mothman to the collapse of the Silver Bridge. Forty-six people perished in that disaster of December 15, 1967. As in the disaster from forty years before, the last body was not found until the following year.
By the way, the first encounter with Mothman took place on November 15, 1966, so sixty years ago this month. Happy Anniversary, Mothman! Mothman was named by a West Virginia reporter based on the vast popularity of the Batman TV show, which also started, like Star Trek, in 1966. "Flying saucer" was also a name coined by a reporter, nineteen years before.
Gray Barker's book about Mothman and the Silver Bridge was The Silver Bridge, published in 1970. Keel's was The Mothman Prophecies, published in 1975. I'm not sure that there was any thought given to respect for the dead or to allow the living a period of mourning before going to print. However, Barker was a native West Virginian and I believe he loved the people of his home state, while Keel dedicated his book to those same people, as well as to newspaper reporter Mary Hyre, his co-investigator during that eventful year of 1967. I should add that Ohio University author Jack Matthews also wrote a book about the collapse of the Silver Bridge. His is at once a humorous and philosophical novel entitled Beyond the Bridge. It was published in 1970 as well. Both Jack Matthews' father and Mary Hyre hailed from Gallia County, Ohio, across the Ohio River from Point Pleasant, West Virginia, home of the Mothman.
I bring up respect for the dead and for their survivors because there are still people who essentially exploit the Silver Bridge disaster for commercial purposes. Much of this is or may be in poor taste, or disrespectful and unthinking towards those who died and those who survived them. It takes their deaths and their losses lightly. I have talked to people who were alive when the people on the bridge died. Some of them knew or were related to those who were lost. Whether they knew the dead or not, they tell stories of shock, disbelief, and great sadness. It's a serious matter, I think, to draw on real, historical suffering, pain, loss, and death for artistic purposes, even more so for commercial purposes. If we're going to do these things, we should proceed with care.
* * *
In "The Whisperer in Darkness," H.P. Lovecraft romanticized--and horrorized (my new word)--a real and realistic event, as well as the country in which it took place. Among his descriptions are these phrases and sentences:
"the wild domed hills of Vermont"
"the unfrequented hills"
"It hinted at a hidden race of monstrous beings which lurked somewhere among the remoter hills--in the deep woods of the highest peaks, and the dark valleys where streams trickle from unknown sources."
"caves of problematical depth"
"things which adventurous people had seen very rarely in the twilight of the remotest valleys and the dense perpendicular woods above the limits of normal hill-climbing."
"the haunted hills"
He also described the people of rural and small-town Vermont I think in an elitist fashion:
"such witnesses--in every case naive and simple backwoods folk"
These are the things that city people think and feel and fear about the country.
Although I'm from the city--Indianapolis--I have lived and worked in hill country in four states. I have to say, the country is not scary. There is nothing threatening or menacing about high hills and deep woods. Country people are also not scary, nor are they necessarily backward and ignorant, which is to say they are no more that way than any other portion of humanity. This attitude, which emanates from the city and especially from the urban middle class, is insulting to them, but it's actually insulting to all of us. We should all refrain from thinking this way.
Lovecraft was well traveled. Nonetheless, he was an urbanite. (The population of Providence, Rhode Island, his native city, was 175,597 in 1900, the year in which he turned 10 years old.) He had his artistic purposes. I think we can let him slide. Although "The Whisperer in Darkness" has its flaws, it's an effective story. On the other hand, Lovecraft's almost Puritan fear and suspicion of wildness, the country, and the people who live in the country extends into several of his stories. His attempts to mimic their speech--accurate or not--are almost comical, but then a focus on speech, accents, idioms, and expressions was a part of our popular culture in the late 1800s and early 1900s. Maybe that kind of focus is part of Regionalism in art and literature. Lovecraft, being an old New Englander and an Anglophile, was also caught up in status and class. He may have lived in dire poverty like a backwoods hillbilly, but he believed himself to be of a higher status, I think. On the other, other hand, Lovecraft wrote stories of urban horror, and so the country wasn't the only place in his Lovecraftian universe where these things could happen.
People who live in small towns and rural areas, in the hills and in the woods, tire of the ways city dwellers see them and the things they think and say about them. Those thoughts and ideas go the other way to be sure, but if I am to think of a rural or small-town author who wrote about the horrors of the city and dealt in equal stereotypes about the people who live there, you will have to give me some time.
* * *
The habits of Lovecraft's crustaceous things from outer space are like those attributed to Bigfoot: scaring people who go into the hills and woods, haunting the edges of human habitation, coming to doors and windows at night, attempting to speak in human language. These similarities lead me to think that Bigfoot and Lovecraft's flying fungi from another planet have a common ancestor in our own earthly folklore.
There is this, too:
The Pennacook myths, which were the most consistent and picturesque, taught that the Winged Ones came from the Great Bear in the sky, and had mines in our earthly hills whence they took a kind of stone they could not get on any other world.
This precedes the idea held among believers in flying saucers that aliens are here to gather samples of soil and rocks, or that they wish to mine minerals that are not available on their own planets. Some even think that aliens are here for our water. A simple economic analysis of such activities would show, I think, that a pile of rocks from earth is not worth the effort, especially considering that you would add so much mass to your return trip that you would need vaster amounts of fuel to make the necessary acceleration. And if you're traveling at close to the speed of light--you would have to in order to fly between stars in a convenient period of time--that mass of rocks would become even more massive the closer you get to c. Again, not worth the effort. Better to synthesize your minerals at home. You obviously have the technology for it if you're winging your way around the galaxy in near-light-speed ships.
As I've said before, flying saucers come not from outer space but from science fiction. Put another way, before these things can be seen, they have to be imagined, and it is science fiction authors and artists who have done the imagining, Lovecraft among them.
* * *
There is a grimoire of sorts in "The Whisperer in Darkness." It is Eli Davenport's "exceedingly rare monograph" on folklore printed in 1839. That sounds like a book Jack Matthews, an active bookman as well as a novelist, would have looked for and cherished. I found a sad real-life event involving a twelve-year-old boy named Eli Davenport who drowned in the Monongahela River in Pennsylvania in July 1912 while saving two other boys from the current. Like the victims of other disasters, his body was not recovered right away.
* * *
I have to comment on Lovecraft's annoying and overused--and wholly unimaginative--expressions: "the old ones" and "elder earth-race," the latter of which is a variation of "elder things" and "elder ones." No one talks this way. In fact, ordinary people are far more creative and colorful in coming up with names for things unfamiliar to them, for example, Mothman or flying saucers, Skunk Ape or Chupacabra. And how often does a Lovecraftian or other pulp-fiction character say that what he sees is indescribable and proceeds to call this indescribable thing "the thing"? Lovecraft and his fellows were wordsmiths and professional writers and yet they fell back again and again on the most colorless and hackneyed of words and phrases. Why?
* * *
Finally:
Lovecraft wrote:
Two or three fanatical extremists went so far as to hint at possible meanings in the ancient Indian tales which gave the hidden beings a non-terrestrial origin; citing the extravagant books of Charles Fort with their claims that voyagers from other worlds and outer space have often visited earth. [Boldface added.]
A few paragraphs before, he had written:
The tales thus brought to my notice came mostly through newspaper cuttings [. . .]. [Emphasis added.]
Lovecraft, then, was aware of the writings of Charles Fort, and his narrator, Wilmarth, availed himself of what I have called the Fortean method, that is, the assembling of evidence or a narrative or even an explanatory theory from newspaper and journal clippings. Gray Barker and John Keel did it decades after the fictional Wilmarth did. Both were thoroughgoing Forteans. In any case, again, in the work of an artist, there is precedent for the beliefs of the real-world flying saucer (and ancient alien) enthusiast, namely "that voyagers from other worlds and outer space have often visited earth."
Original text copyright 2026 Terence E. Hanley

No comments:
Post a Comment