For Thanksgiving, here's an illustration from Weird Tales by Andrew Brosnatch. It looks like it could be for "Young Goodman Brown" by Nathaniel Hawthorne, but according to my index of the magazine, Hawthorne's story (from May 1927) was not accompanied by an illustration.
This cover, from August 1928, illustrates Robert E. Howard's story "Red Shadows" and depicts a colorfully dressed Puritan in the person of Solomon Kane. No dour black broadcloth for him. The art is by C.C. Senf.